Getting your internet from an orbiting earth satellite sounds pretty awesome, doesn’t it? Are you ready to switch right now? Hopefully not since satellite internet remains the absolute last option for most consumers, perhaps with the exception of…dial-up internet service. However, if you live in rural areas or locations without DSL/fiber/cable internet providers, then satellite internet may be your only choice.
Of course, Satellite communications (SATCOM) are a mainstay of the US and most foreign governments as satellites, both commercial and government-owned, provide invaluable capabilities. Having a dedicated satellite for SATCOM allows for the most robust and effective security posture, as government agencies can deploy encryption algorithms and secured protocols that greatly enhance their network security relative to the world-wide internet. And the ability to deploy military satellites over war zones or other areas of national security interest is critical to mission success.
In today’s blog, we’ll discuss satellite internet in broad terms and also dig a little deeper into the current state-of-the-art and discuss the inherent challenges that satellite internet poses and how many of these shortcomings can be addressed using satellite bonding with SD-WAN routers. We’ll discuss how current satellite internet providers are providing internet access and talk about future plans – and there are some BIG plans indeed. Let’s get started.
Currently, satellite internet is provided to consumers via communication satellites in geostationary earth orbit (GEO). These satellites are all distributed around the equator (0 degrees latitude) at various longitudes and at a distance of 22,236 miles. At this distance the satellite’s time-to-orbit perfectly matches the earth’s rotation rate, and so the satellite remains “fixed” relative to a ground observer as the earth rotates. This means that you can always locate that particular satellite at the same spot, regardless of time of day or time of year. The GEO satellites can potentially illuminate thousands of square miles which means you don’t need very many of them to cover an entire continent.
Some interesting trivia about GEO is that it was first popularized by the prolific science fiction writer Arthur C. Clarke in the 1940s and the first GEO satellite was launched in 1963.
If you want to use SATCOM for your regular internet usage, you need a home satellite dish to communicate with the satellite. These dishes are relatively small, typically 18”-30” in diameter and would be provided and mounted on your roof by the provider, locked in place so it is always pointing at the satellite. You also need some cabling running from your satellite dish to your satellite modem located inside your home or office.
So now you can communicate with the satellite in both downlink and uplink directions. But the lone satellite orbiting the earth doesn’t know anything about the internet and how to identify specific domains and/or IP addresses. To get information about the internet, the satellite needs to communicate with another (much larger) ground-based satellite dish and associated technology, typically referred to as the Network Operations Center, or NOC. The NOC acts as the internet gateway for the satellite so all internet traffic flows between the NOC and the satellite.
There are several significant and inherent problems with satellite internet using GEO satellites. They can generally be broken down into 4 areas:
Performance Enhancing Proxies (PEPs)
Due to all the inherent performance issues with SATCOM (particularly latency), performance-enhancing proxies (PEPs) have been developed to improve the overall performance. Wikipedia defines PEPs as “network agents designed to improve the end-to-end performance of some communication protocols.”
PEPs can be classified according to three general classes:
A PEP that is commonly used in SATCOM to reduce latency is Split-TCP which works by breaking a single TCP session into multiple sessions and then using custom parameters (such as larger window sizes) to control transmission on each leg. Other PEP types include Ack decimation, Snoop, and D-proxy.
Satellite Bonding using SD-WAN
Performance enhancing proxies are network agents that help with some of the inherent issues, particularly latency, with SATCOM. However, many underlying issues still remain. Another very promising technique for dramatically improving SATCOM involves the SD-WAN technologies that are capable of bonding of the satellite links either with another satellite connection or with other, wired, broadband transports, such as DSL, cable, and/or fiber. SD-WAN solutions with specialized algorithms are required to cope with the higher than normal latencies of SATCOM.
Current Satellite Internet Providers
Currently there are two dominant providers of satellite internet – ViaSat and HughesNet. A recent review comparing the two providers can be found here, on reviews.org.
Below I’ve listed some specs for baseline plans from each provider, just to get a quick comparison:
ViaSat Unlimited Bronze 12 Plan
What About Low Earth Orbit Satellites?
If using GEO satellites causes such debilitating latency while using the internet and performing other mission-critical communications, aren’t there other options? There sure are and there is a lot of work being done right now to utilize both Medium Earth Orbit (MEO) and Low Earth Orbit (LEO) satellites. Actually, the correct term to use is “satellite constellations” since these solutions rely on many satellites working together and sharing information in a more networked/mesh type of environment, rather than a single GEO satellite illuminating half of CONUS.
LEO satellites orbit at a distance of 500-1000 miles and MEO satellites orbit at a distance of ~8000 miles. So for LEO constellations, there is promise for latency to be greatly reduced to values approaching current, wired-internet norms. But there are still major technological challenges to fielding interconnected systems (constellations) of LEO/MEO satellites:
Many of these challenges are already being addressed with the 1-2 thousand satellites currently in MEO and LEO orbit. Several companies are launching more satellites this year and according to Northern Sky Research, “over 4,000 Non-GEO HTS satellites are forecasted to launch by 2028, from OneWeb, SpaceX, Telesat, LeoSat, Amazon, and SES.”
Currently, satellite internet is a great option to have in rural areas or other locations where wired internet is not available. While performance right now is not very good, over the next few years performance, pricing, and availability are all moving in the right direction for consumers.
For mission-critical SATCOM use cases, performance enhancing proxies and SD-WAN bonding of the satellite links can significantly improve end-to-end performance.
Rob Stone, Mushroom Networks, Inc.
Mushroom Networks is the provider of Broadband Bonding appliances that put your networks on auto-pilot. Application flows are intelligently routed around network problems such as latency, jitter and packet loss. Network problems are solved even before you can notice.
© 2004 – 2023 Mushroom Networks Inc. All rights reserved.
Let’s chat. Call us at +1 (858) 452-1031 or fill the form:
Download your copy of rare tips and tricks for a better WAN. Get your free copy today!
We respect your privacy.
4 thoughts on “Satellite Internet – A Quick Primer and Survey of Solutions to Improve Performance”
Rob, I am looking into this solution for a client of mine. He lives in a remote cabin with viasat Internet. Speeds range from 3-30Mbps, its very inconsistent. We have thought about adding another connection and bonding both systems. Is this a feasible solution? Would he realize increased speeds? He does alot of Video and Zoom meetings. What would it take to do this?
Thank you for your question. Yes, indeed combining 2 or more Satcom transports is possible. Depending on the application type, Mushroom Networks has various tunnel options that maximizes the application performance for applications such as video, audio, VPN, file transfer and others. I believe you are already connected with one of our solutions experts, so they will be able to provide you the recommendation for the best match for bonding satellite modems. Btw, you can also combine satellite with other types of Internet connections such as 3G/4G LTE/5G wireless or any other wired Internet.
Yes I understand, problem is there is NO DSL or LTE at this site, just Viasat. Would we be better off to have Hughes AND Viasat together?
If there is only satellite Internet available, then yes, you can aggregate two or more satellite modems (from the same provider or different providers).
Comments are closed.